Acting: 10 Italian Coffees out 10
Writing: 9 Single-Bed Hotel Rooms out of 10
Directing: 10 Lonely Hallways out of 10
Overall: 10 May-December Romances out of 10
Goes well with:
Love Actually, Closet LandRichard Curtis has had an interesting career. British comedy buffs know him as the mastermind behind
The Black Adder BBC series. Romance buffs know him as the writer of
Four Weddings and a Funeral, Love Actually, and many others. But this film is a tad unusual for him; normally a Curtis film hits the ground running, but this one starts and stops, dithers about abit awkwardly, and then suddenly launches forward with enough charm and poignancy to adore the film.
And it's done that way on purpose, from the dialog to the filming style to the superb performance by Bill Nighy. That man is a treasure, whether he's the charismatically vicious Viktor in the
Underworld series or the past-his-prime rock star in
Love Actually (which is wonderful film even for people who aren't romance buffs). I'll watch Nighy in anything...and believe me, the beginning of this film is so dry and awkward (two shy people thrown together try to get to know each other, and then he's obsessing on her and doesn't know how to handle it) that it was pretty much Nighy himself that kept me watching. Kelly MacDonald (the original
State of Play BBC mini,
Tristam Shandy, No Country for Old Men) is a wonderful "straight man" for Nighy's actions, grounding the picture while not trying to compete...she's quietly adorable and a solid counterpoint. She's so natural in the role it doesn't look like acting.
The framing of shots is not only gorgeously done, it's almost a supporting character in and of itself. David Yates (again, the original
State of Play, the last three
Harry Potter films) is a top shelf filmmaker, and used his framing to emphasize Nighy's character's loneliness. This could have easily have been bungled, either hitting the audience over the head by trying too hard, or else just coming across as weird, but the man has the rare eye of a world-class still photographer. You could capture about 230 frames from this film and use them as framed prints on your wall. It's stunning, and completely drives the point home to one's heart.
Plot-wise, the story's a bit non-traditional. Older lonely man accidentally meets younger woman and a relationship blooms, not out of sexual desire but out of sheer personality attraction and (here's that word again) loneliness. (Thanks to the aforementioned filming, they don't take too much time on him being alone...keeping the audience from getting bored.) But then things take an odd turn when he invites her to the G8 summit, where he's a financial advisor for the UK contingent, and a normal girl gets thrust in contact with the movers and shakers and starts to voice, inappropriately, her opinions on helping the poor and dying, a 5-year old G8 promise many countries are overlooking at the summit. This isn't the blundering of Bridget Jones (which Curtis adapted for the screen), but rather serious drama. (This would be where
Closet Land comes into play.) This film is really two flicks in one...which is often how life works, and something Curtis has shown a fine hand in writing.
Is this a film for everyone? Certainly not. But it is very much a film for anyone who's a fan of anyone who loves any of the talent involved...they all shine...and a great introduction to them if you're new but love the quieter pictures that still manage, with top-notch acting and beautiful writing, to make you laugh and feel at the same time.
http://www.amazon.com/Girl-Cafe-Bill-Nig
hy/dp/B000A59PL0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=dv
d&qid=1263138303&sr=8-1